
< back
to full review list
< back
to academic authors review list
< back
to textbook authors review list
Franklin
H. Silverman
Publishing for Tenure and Beyond
This book is intended
for both assistant professors and graduate students who are planning
to pursue a career in college teaching, states the author, who has written
more than a dozen books and more than 100 journal articles.
After referring to obtaining tenure as a game and publishing as a rule
of the game, Silverman lists some rules for the Publishing for Tenure Game including:
- A participant
must have the courage to write.
- The manuscript
shows both an awareness and understanding of relevant contemporary
literature and the literature review is sharply focused.
- The findings
reported are related to the existing body of knowledge.
Silverman advises
writers to learn to accept rejection as "part of the game" Researchers
should seek extra-mural funding and involve students in the research,
he writes.
Beginning authors should be "low profile" with colleagues, especially
about any income-producing work, but should be "high profile" with deans,
department heads and vice presidents.
One important point stressed by Silverman is to produce projects that
are peer-reviewed. At least one peer-reviewed publication each year
in a respected journal is a good goal, he writes. Silverman discusses
various publishing options, ranging from printed scholarly journals
to letters to the editor. He comments that including non-academic publications
in a tenure portfolio might be frowned upon. Various book-publishing
options are discussed.
Chapter Six deals with "Creating an Article, Book or Material." The
author discusses how an effective writing schedule can become addictive.
He presents tips to make writing successful. One interesting bit of
trivia is that 27 percent of college text authors used legal pads for
writing a first draft.
Other chapters deal with copyright and fair use, ethical issues, funding
research and publishing with a collaborator. One section discusses considerations
when seeking a co-author.
Although the primary focus is on publishing for tenure, Silverman includes
a chapter on publishing after tenure. It has a section on post-tenure
review, and options for post-tenure publishing are discussed.
The final chapter, "They Rejected It! Now What?" was "frankly an afterthought,"
writes Silverman. He presents erroneous assumptions about submitting
manuscripts and then refutes them. The book closes on an up note: "as
soon as you can after having a manuscript or proposal rejected, make
whatever changes you think are necessary and submit it to another publisher."
This book achieves its stated purpose of providing guidance for assistant
professors and graduate students in the publication for tenure game.
However, it includes much useful material for those who have achieved
tenure but plan to continue playing the publication game. I recommend
it.
OTHER COMMENTS
"Silverman provides not only useful, but essential guidance to college
faculty and other professionals interested in a respectable and
increasingly popular alternative to commercial publishing houses.
I recommend this book highly to any author who is interested in
publishing his or her own material."
- --
John F. Wakefield (education), University of North Alabama
"I wish this
book had been available before I started self-publishing. It describes
almost all the ins and outs of self-publishing that I have encountered--plus
many more. With self-publishing becoming more popular and acceptable,
it seems that any writer would benefit from the knowledge that is
locked within the pages of Dr. Silverman's book."
- -- Jerome
A. Halvorson (communications disorders), University of Wisconsin-River
Falls
"One wonders
why this book, or at least one like it, wasn't written and published
long ago. Using both his own and others experience, Dr. Silverman
presents a practical, highly readable overview of the entire self-publishing
process. The book is quite thorough and gives equal weight to the
arguments for and against academic self-publishing. There are practical
suggestions, cautions, and examples. Any academic author comtemplating
self-publishing should purchase this book and study it carefully."
- --
Robert D. Moulton associate vice president. for research
and graduate dean, Lamar University
|
Review by
GENE MURRAY
Grambling State University
ISBN: X0-9636670-2-5
$29.95
229 pages
Praeger
New York
1999
|