
< back
to full column list
< back
to academic authors column list
< back
to textbook authors column list
Collaboration
Between and Among Co-authors
By
Michael Lennie

MICHAEL LENNIE
Lennie Literary Agency & Author's Attorneys
2255 Avenida de la Playa
La Jolla, CA 92037
858-456-0138
858-456-1893 fax
www.lennieliterary.com
michael@lennieliterary.com
Lennie is an attorney who represents textbook authors.
Because
collaboration matters generally not addressed in author-publisher
contracts, it's wise to provide for such an agreement whether
your collaborator is a close friend or colleague or a complete
stranger.
This is
adapted from the July 1991 issue of TAA Report.
© 1991,
Michael R. Lennie. All rights reserved.
|
Perhaps you are
considering a joint writing effort with a colleague. Or maybe you've
just been selected as part of a K-8 writing team for a basal text. Likely,
the question will arise, "Should we have some type of agreement between
ourselves, or will the author-publisher contract take care of everything?"
Because collaboration matters generally are not addressed in author-publisher
contracts, it's wise to provide for such an agreement whether your collaborator
is a close friend or colleague or a complete stranger.
Purpose. One of the primary purposes of any contract is to provide a level of
certainty that the reasonable expectations of the parties will be realized.
One of the effects of negotiating a contract is to force the parties
to articulate their reasonable expectations. The process has the effect
of causing all parties to enter a contract only after they have made
their best efforts to anticipate and provide for the various circumstances
that may arise during the life of their agreement.
What should a collaboration
agreement include? Let's look at some of the more significant clauses
of any collaboration agreement. You can't provide for every circumstance
that may arise, but you can cover 95 percent of them with a good agreement.
The result will be a business-like relationship with less room for misunderstanding.
Determine responsibility
for work. If you are collaborating on a single text or text and
supplementary materials, the first concern Involves the respective responsibilities
of the authors. If you start by developing an outline of the text, it
then becomes easy to assign chapters or subjects to each author. If
you are an author on a K-8 writing team it is likely the publisher has
already done this. In any event the agreement should set forth the primary
responsibilities of each author with respect to the work.
Develop a time
line. Your author-publisher contract calls for a final manuscript'
by a certain date. Counting back from that date, construct a reasonable
schedule for generation of manuscript. If you have done this before
you are at an advantage. If this Is your first text, talk to someone
who has published a few similar texts. But be sure to talk to them about
how long it took to write their first text, not their 10th.
Talk to a few experienced
authors, bearing in mind that each has different work habits and productivity.
Add in time for unexpected delays such as minor Illnesses, writer's
block, publisher's changed plans, editor's vacation or illness, change
of editor, and other variables. The time line can be attached to and
incorporated as a part of your collaboration agreement, or can remain
as an informal document without strict contractual ramifications. In
either event the time line may be used to develop realistic scheduling
for the completion of work.
Final editorial
and creative control. Perhaps you have already given this up in
your author-publisher contract. If not, consider dealing with it here.
It may be one of the authors has superior editorial talents, or is far
more experienced. If so, this author might be given artistic control
over the project with authority to negotiate final editorial changes
with the editor. As an alternative, you might authorize the more experienced
author to engage in all preliminary editing with the less experienced
author retaining rights to final approval (more cumbersome, but isn't
democracy always so?)
The business
side of book writing. Another job for the more experienced of the
authors is the business aspects of your collaborative effort. For example,
the selection of an attorney to assist in the negotiation of the author-publisher
contract. The more experienced author will have more contacts to turn
up the right attorney for you. While the collaborative agreement may
designate the more experienced author as point man on negotiations,
it should be made clear that all authors must sign any third party agreement.
Set a budget. Your author-publisher contract may impose certain production costs on
the author. Be sure you are aware of all such costs or potential costs
to be borne by the author. I have seen first-time authors sign book
contracts calling for authors to pay 50 percent of art costs in elementary
school texts. The result was hundreds of thousands of royalty dollars
going to relieve the publisher of production costs.
Your collaboration
agreement should budget for all such costs, including:
- Author travel. This may Include uncompensated travel to New York to meet with your
publisher; or travel to Cleveland to meet with your co-author; or
travel to Europe to view the Mona Lisa featured on the cover of your
art education text.
- Art costs. See above)
- Cost of author-paid
permissions.
- Typing costs.
- Assistance. Costs paid to a college student to help preparae a workbook, index
or table of contents.
Set a budget and
incorporate it by reference as an exhibit to your collaboration agreement.
Credits. The time to see whether ego is going to stand in the way of a beautiful
relationship is before you are a year and a half into your book. Who
is named first? If one author is a better draw by reason of past publications
or some other claim to fame, by all means put your best foot forward.
If all co-authors are roughly on par, go with an alphabetical listing
or a coin flip.
Advances. Money Is a great motivator. Consider providing In your collaboration
agreement for a joint interest-bearing account to hold your advance
money, with release requiring the signature of all collaborators pegged
to certain completion points In the manuscript. Note: This is not practical
if your advances are so small that bank service charges exceed interest;
or your "advance" is really a late payment for work already performed.
Money. Share
and share alike? Quite often this is the best arrangement. However,
there are a number of factors that weigh in favor of something other
than a 50-50 split of royalties: superior knowledge, writing skills,
experience and name recognition are just a few. It may be that one author
will do two-thirds of the work. An illustrator may not get as much as
the author unless his name is Garry Trudeau. Whatever the circumstances,
don't be afraid to discuss what you think is fair.
Competition clause. You know that terrible competition clause In your author-publisher contract,
the one I rail against in author workshops. You need one here. If your
work is published, you don't want one co-author publishing a competing
text that will undermine sales of the work. And If your work isn't published
you don't want one co-author taking jointly authored material as his
own to a new publisher.
Duration of agreement. How long should your collaboration agreement be in effect? For the same
time as the life of the copyright to your work. In the case of a jointly
authored text the term should be for 76 years plus renewals and extensions.
Arbitration of
disputes. Most authors cannot afford a lengthy litigation over a
collaboration agreement. The best means to an abbreviated, relatively
inexpensive and quick resolution of dispute is a clause that calls for
binding arbitration of all disputes before an arbitrator. The American
Arbitration Association rules may be stipulated to in this clause. You
may also wish to adopt the laws of a particular state, and preset the
forum where the matter will be heard, e. g., Peoria, Illinois.
Warranties and
indemnities clause. Another dreaded clause from the author-publisher
contract is particularly appropriate here even if (and it will be) included
in your author-publisher contract. The promise in the author-publisher
contract is to the publisher, and of no avail to the co-author. Since
a third-party will name you as well as your plagiarizing or defaming
co-author in any lawsuit (and prevail as to your joint liability), you
need the protection of a warranty from your co-author that everything
be original and nonlibelous, together with an indemnity against damages
and costs in defense In the event the warranty Is breached.
Termination. An important part of your collaboration agreement is the provision for
termination of the agreement. Termination may occur by reason of death
or disability, unwillingness or inability to complete the work or by
reason of irreconcilable differences between the authors. It may be
that a far better offer comes along, making the 10th revision of your
collaborative workGuide To Window Washing seem somewhat pedestrian
by comparison. Yes, there Is such a book.
The issues to be
addressed in thie termination section of the collaboration agreement:
- Who gets control
of the incomplete manuscript and supporting and supplementary materials?
- What will be
the arrangements for royalty sharing should the work be published?
- Who pays for
completion of the work?
- Will there be
a change in the previously agreed-to credits order?
The answer to who
gets control of the manuscript may be obvious or it may be difficult.
When one member of a two-member writing team dies, the survivor should
take control, complete the work, or make provisions for completion and
go forward with publication. The collaboration agreement could fairly
provide that the royalty split set forth in the agreement will prevail
for the current edition, with the deceased author's royalty account
charged for the expense of completing the deceased author's share of
the work.
There should be
some schedule for reduction of the deceased author's share of royalties
in subsequent editions. For example, the collaboration agreement could
provide for the decedent's estate to receive 60 percent of the royalties
provided for in the collaboration agreement for the first revision following
completion of the work in progress, 30 percent for the second such revision,
and 16 percent for each revision thereafter.
If your co-author's
name is James Michener, don't mess with the order of credits no matter
how dead he is. If you and your co-author are co-equal draws but you
lost the coin flip, you should have provisions for a change In the order
of credits In the first revision following completion of the work in
progress at the time of death.
Where the collaboration
agreement is terminating by reason of a failing out between two authors,
the agreement may call for completion by the author best suited to complete
the work in a manner most likely to result in successful publication.
It is quite possible you could not possibly reach an objective determination
following a deterioration of the relationship. In that event it is particularly
important that you have an arbitrator or some objective third party
provided for In your collaboration agreement to make this determination.
Amendmcnts. Provide that all amendments to the agreement must be in writing and
signed by all authors.
Attorney fees. If your co-author contract dispute goes to trial and you are forced
to hire an attorney to defend or prosecute the action, the only way
you can recover your attorney's fee is if you provide for attorney's
fees to the prevailing party in the collaboration agreement. An attorney's
fee clause is a strong disincentive to the bringing of meritless or
marginal suits. A party will think twice before risking the payment
of two sets of attorney's fees. Consequently, an attorney's fees clause
provides incentives to all parties to settle. Lastly, an attorney's
fee clause is an empowering provision. With such a clause, one need
not be intimidated from bringing a meritorious case for fear the attorney's
fees will exceed the amount in controversy.
As an aside, this
empowering aspect is precisely why you have never seen an attorney's
fee clause in an author-publisher contract. Publishers can easily afford
to hire an attorney. Knowing that you can't allows publishers to be
far more cavalier in their treatment of authors.
Of course with or
without an attorney's fee clause, you are always better off settling
your dispute with some compromise -- and thus face saving on both sides.
A settlement normally results In both financial and emotional savings.
Conclusion. A collaboration agreement is important in many situations, and on occasion
even vital. In addition the process of defining your goals and respective
duties can in and of itself be a worthwhile exercise. While we have
not had in-depth discussion in this column regarding the effect of your
author-publisher contract on your collaboration agreement, and vice
versa, it is important to coordinate the provisions of the two agreements
to avoid contradictory provisions.
|